jelly beans - select marketing agency - refresh marketing

How to select a marketing agency

After deciding which type of marketing agency you want (see our previous article here), you will need to decide on the process you want to follow to select a marketing agency. Start by identifying your business needs, and the characteristics you want from your outsourced marketing resource.

The process for selecting a marketing agency

The agency selection process should be a straightforward and rational process that should follow a number of well-defined steps. It’s best to approach the process as a project in itself, with a clearly defined process, team and desired outcomes.

Here is an outline of the process for a full agency selection procedure.

1. Define agency requirements

Firstly, decide what you need from a marketing agency. Refer to our earlier article which describes the type of marketing agencies that exist which serves as a useful starting point. Beyond this, create a list of requirements specific to your company or project – for example do they need experience of your sector, be geographically close to your place of business, have experience of specific marketing channels or specialist skills?

Take a look below at our suggested criteria for agency selection.

2. Create a long list of agencies

Do your research to identify a long list of suitable agencies. Sometimes an agent or pitch consultant can be used to help you with this task as it takes experience of the sector to know which agencies are experienced in each discipline. This is known as the ‘pool list’, which means it is a list of potential agencies that would meet the requirements set out by you.

3. Where to find agencies

The starting point for agencies should be recommendations from your peers. We get the vast majority of our work from past clients who recommend our services. Look beyond your current organization and ask your contacts in similar companies, your wider network and companies whose marketing you admire.

Check out which agencies have won awards in relevant classifications, who is being talked about in the press and are members of professional bodies such as the IPA.

Finally, Google, LinkedIn and other social media networks can provide you with further insight into which agencies are out there and performing well. Ask your LinkedIn network for recommendations, and check out each agency’s social channels. If they’re not sharing great content themselves then perhaps they are not on top of their marketing game.

4. Credentials pitch and shortlisting

Agencies can be approached to provide details of their skills and past experience. This is known as ‘credentials’. They may be invited to a meeting or asked to present their credentials before a full project brief is issued. This stage allows you to narrow down the list of agencies to a shortlist for the briefing stage. More often than not this information is available on the agency website, but you may want to contact them anyway in case they have more relevant case studies or other examples they can share with you.

4. Agency briefing stage

Next you need to work up a project brief to give to the shortlisted agencies from which they can develop a full pitch. As this demands a significant time investment from agencies some clients offer a pitch budget for this stage to recompense the agency for the time invested.

Gone are the days of inviting several agencies to deliver a full pitch for a speculative piece of work. Agencies run pretty lean operations, so they are likely only to respond with a full pitch if they are in the running for a significant account win.

For a smaller project it is not reasonable to ask an agency to deliver full ideas and creative at this stage before engagement. More likely, agencies will respond with an outline strategy or draft concepts (sketches) to demonstrate their expertise without incurring significant resource costs.

agency pitch presentation4. Full pitch meeting

After an agreed number of weeks, the shortlisted agencies present their work to the client at a pitch meeting. This is the agencies opportunity to wow the client with their strategy, creative concepts and quality of delivery.

5. Evaluation of the agency pitch

Consider your criteria for assessing one agency against another and how you will reach a decision. Have this agreed upfront before the pitch meetings. It’s best to have a small number of experienced team members involved in the process, with some junior team members to build their exposure to the process. Everyone should grade their assessment of the agency against each pre-agreed criteria so that a total score and observations can be discussed after the meetings.

6. Select a winning agency

Alongside the criteria above you will need to consider softer criteria such as chemistry with the team, who you will be working with, and their communication style. Based on the overall assessment your team will select the winner and inform all agencies of the decision.

If you are appointing more than one agency, for instance for a rosta of agencies, or multiple agencies with complimentary specialisms you will need to ensure that they are comfortable working in this way. Some agencies prefer to have all aspects of an account in-house rather than collaborating with other suppliers.

7. Define the team

Gain clarity over who will be working with you. Some agencies like to roll out the big guns for pitch meetings, however it is unlikely that they will be actively working on your project. Ask for confirmation of who your Account Manager will be, as they will be your day to day contact, and who the team is that will be actively working on your project.

Likewise this is a good time for you to define who your key contacts are who will be responsible for liaising with the agency(ies).

8. Contract agreement

Contracts then need to be signed off with agencies, including details of remuneration and services to be provided.

9. Agree a review process

Consider how frequently you will review the agency working relationship, aside from the day to day of project delivery. A quarterly meeting of senior contacts on both sides is a good idea so that you can reflect together on how the relationship is going, and agree on any changes needed.

Suggested criteria to select a marketing agency

agency selection criteria checklistSome of these criteria are useful in the initial long-listing stage of the process, with other criteria more useful in the later pitch stage. Define what matters to you, or use all the criteria below for your rating scale.

Size of the agency compared to the organisation is a key criteria. Smaller organisations tend to work better with smaller agencies, as the culture of both organisations is more likely to be aligned. Likewise, international or global organisations may need international or global agencies to enable a larger or more complex campaign to be delivered across regions.

A smaller agency is likely to get a little lost within a large agency, and find that their work is deprioritised against that of larger (and higher paying) clients. Try to find an agency where your company will be mid-range, so that you are large enough to matter without being the largest account they have. You will want to gain from the agency’s experience with other, bigger budget clients, so it’s good if they have some other big clients that you can learn from.

Specialism of the agency is central to your criterial, based on the requirements of your organization or specific campaign. How many team members do they have in your chosen area, and can they withstand any team departures? You don’t want to appoint an agency only to find that their key expertise has just walked out the door.

Range of services they offer. Do you want a specialist agency with specific expertise, or an agency that can cover a number of your supplier needs. Consider the wider range of services that the agency can offer and whether it makes sense to have a number of these under one roof. If you only need them for specific disciplines be wary of the agency selling you services you don’t want or need.

Agency client list is important as you may want to check that they don’t work with any of your key competitors which may create a conflict of interest. This poses problems for niche agencies who specialize in particular sectors as they are likely to work with similar companies who could be in competition with you. Agencies often overcome this with ‘chinese walls’ which is the idea that a separation of the agency teams will ensure that information is not shared. I’ll leave it to you to decide whether that is realistic or not within an agency setting, where creative work can be displayed on the walls and best practice shared across teams.

Track record and reputation are useful criteria to consider, and can include campaign awards won, testimonials and client references.

Creative thinking – how good is the agency at coming up with ideas that resonate with the target audience, will cut-through the noise and support the key messages of your campaign. How well do they understand your brand, company values and business objectives?

Compatibility (chemistry) can be argued to be one of the most important criteria for selecting an agency. Your team needs to be able to develop a good working relationship with the team, have honest feedback sessions and co-create excellent creative solutions together.

Criticality – is your agency likely to challenge your thinking and bring recommendations to push your marketing forward? Is this a capability that you want from your agency, or do you have a clearly defined strategy that needs a focus on quality implementation?

In summary

Selecting a marketing agency can be a time consuming process, and is expensive if you get it wrong. Take time to define your process and criteria before you start shortlising so that you can be as objective as possible about the agency selection process.

Need some help in selecting a new marketing agency? Our experienced consultants can help. Contact us today.

 

Credit: Fill, 2013